Tax included and shipping calculated at checkout
- Posted on
925 Sterling Silver vs Silver-Plated: What You're Actually Paying For
Online, you cannot tell them apart. That's not a failure of your judgement — it's the entire commercial logic of the ₹499 bracelet. It's designed to be indistinguishable in the only place you'll ever see it before buying.
Six months in, they are not remotely the same object. Here's the whole picture, including the part most jewellery brands leave out.
What 925 sterling silver actually is
92.5% pure silver, 7.5% other metal — usually copper.
That's it. That's the entire definition, and the number is where the name comes from.
The obvious question is why not use 100% silver. The answer is that pure silver is genuinely too soft to be useful. You can dent it with a fingernail. A pure-silver ring goes oval in a pocket; a pure-silver clasp opens under its own weight; a pure-silver setting won't grip a stone. The 7.5% copper is what turns a beautiful metal into a wearable one.
Sterling is the international standard for fine silver jewellery and has been for roughly eight centuries. When something is sterling, the silver runs all the way through it. File it, scratch it, cut it in half — it's silver at every depth. There is nothing underneath to be exposed.
What silver-plated actually is
A different metal — nearly always brass, sometimes zinc alloy or steel — with a coating of silver deposited on the outside.
The number that matters is thickness, and it's measured in microns. Decent-quality plating might be 3 to 5 microns. The ₹499 bracelet is often under 1 micron. For scale, a sheet of paper is about 100 microns thick.
That coating is subject to ordinary friction. Your wrist, your sleeve, your steering wheel, your laptop edge. It wears from the high points first — the edges of links, the shoulders of a ring, the back of a pendant where it rests against skin. And when it goes, what shows through is brass: yellow-pink, unmistakable, and impossible to fix. You cannot polish a plated item back to health, because polishing removes plating. The cure is the disease.
The skin reactions start around the same time. Brass and cheap alloys frequently contain nickel, which is the single most common contact allergen in jewellery. As long as the plating is intact it acts as a barrier. Once it wears through, the nickel is in direct contact with skin — which is why so many people discover a "silver allergy" they don't actually have.
The one that confuses everyone: rhodium-plated sterling silver
This is where honest brands lose people, so let's be direct about it, because our own pieces fall into this category.
Most quality sterling silver jewellery — ours included — carries a thin plating of rhodium, a platinum-group metal. Our site calls this "lifetime plating." It's worth understanding what that is and isn't.
The key difference: the base metal is still sterling silver. Rhodium isn't hiding brass. It's sitting on top of solid 925 silver to add hardness and slow tarnishing, because rhodium doesn't oxidise the way silver does.
So when rhodium plating eventually thins after years of wear, what shows through is… silver. Slightly warmer in tone, slightly more prone to tarnish, and completely fine. A jeweller can re-plate it for a modest fee, or you can leave it and let it patina.
Compare that to plated brass, where wear reveals a different, cheaper, allergenic metal, and the piece is finished. Same word, opposite outcome. Ask which metal is underneath, not whether something is plated.
Six ways to tell them apart
- Look for the stamp. Genuine sterling is marked 925, S925, or Sterling, usually inside a ring band, on a clasp, or on a pendant bail. No stamp isn't proof of fake, but on anything sold as sterling, its absence is a question worth asking.
- The magnet test. Silver is not magnetic. If a fridge magnet grabs the piece, there's steel or iron in there and it isn't solid silver. (Passing this test doesn't prove sterling — brass isn't magnetic either — but failing it is conclusive.)
- The ice test. Silver has the highest thermal conductivity of any metal. Put an ice cube on a silver piece and it melts noticeably faster than it would on brass or steel. Slightly theatrical, genuinely works.
- Weight in the hand. Silver is dense. A solid sterling bracelet feels heavier than it looks; plated brass usually feels lighter than expected. This one takes a bit of experience, which is an argument for handling pieces in a shop before buying online.
- Watch how it ages. Both tarnish, but differently. Sterling darkens evenly to grey-black and wipes clean. Plated brass goes patchy, greens at the contact points, and shows warm yellow at the edges. The colour of the failure tells you what's underneath.
- Run the price sanity check. Look up the day's silver rate per gram, multiply by the piece's weight, and you have the raw metal cost before any craft, design, plating, or margin. If the selling price is below that number, the piece is not solid silver. It cannot be.
Decoding the words on the listing
The vocabulary is doing a lot of work in this category:
- "German silver," "nickel silver," "Alpaca silver," "Tibetan silver" — contain no silver whatsoever. These are copper-nickel-zinc alloys named after their colour. Perfectly legal, entirely misleading.
- "Silver-tone," "silver finish," "silver colour" — decorative language. No silver content implied or promised.
- "Sterling silver plated" — plated with sterling, over base metal. Reads like the real thing. Isn't.
- "Pure silver," "999 silver" — genuinely higher purity than sterling, but too soft for most jewellery. Fine for coins and bars; a poor choice for a bracelet you'll actually wear.
- "Italian silver" — refers to manufacturing origin and chain-making technique, not to a different purity. Italian chains have a real reputation for quality, but the metal is still 925.
The five-year arithmetic
A ₹499 plated bracelet worn regularly has a working life of roughly six to twelve months before the plating breaks down. Over five years, that's five or six replacements — call it ₹2,500 to ₹3,000, ignoring the shipping and the irritation and the fact that you're never wearing something you love, only something you're waiting to replace.
A ₹3,000 sterling piece worn for the same five years costs ₹3,000, and at the end of it you still own it. It can be re-polished, re-plated, resized, repaired, inherited, or melted for its metal value.
The plated item is a rental you never stop paying for. That's not a moral argument for spending more — there are perfectly good reasons to buy a ₹499 bracelet for a single wedding — it's just the actual maths, which almost nobody does.
Three questions worth asking any seller
- What is the base metal? The important question, and the one that separates rhodium-over-sterling from silver-over-brass.
- What is the piece's weight in grams? Sellers of solid silver will tell you. It's the number that lets you check the price yourself.
- What's the exchange window if it doesn't fit? Ours is set out in our cancellation and exchange policy.
FAQs
Does 925 silver turn your finger green? Very rarely. Green marks come from copper reacting with skin acids and moisture, and at 7.5% there isn't enough copper in sterling to do it for most people. If it does happen, it's usually humidity or lotion, and a clear coat on the inside of the band solves it. Plated brass, which is mostly copper, is a different story.
Is tarnish a sign of fake silver? The opposite. Tarnish is silver reacting with sulphur in the air — it's evidence there's silver present. It's a surface film, not damage, and a dry polishing cloth removes it in seconds. Skip toothpaste and baking soda; both are abrasive enough to permanently dull the finish.
Can silver-plated jewellery be re-plated? Technically yes, but the cost usually approaches the price of a new sterling piece, so almost nobody does it.
How should I store silver in Mumbai? Humidity accelerates tarnish, so an airtight pouch or a lined box with a silica gel sachet makes a real difference. Store pieces separately — silver scratches silver — and put jewellery on after perfume and moisturiser, not before.
Every piece we make is 925 sterling silver. Not plated brass, not silver-tone, not German silver. If you're in Mumbai, come and pick it up — Shop 2, 3, 4, Paras Darshan, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Ghatkopar East, daily 10 AM to 7 PM. Ten minutes of handling real silver teaches you more than any article can.
Buying for Raksha Bandhan? Order by 24 August for delivery before 28 August. Use RAKHI15 for 15% off orders above ₹2,999, and free shipping applies above ₹2,499.
Read Also
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on
- Posted on